?

Log in

No account? Create an account
Doctor Who – Smith and Jones (rant warning) - Stephan [entries|archive|friends|userinfo]
Stephan

[ website | Kaustic auZzie Notes ]
[ userinfo | livejournal userinfo ]
[ archive | journal archive ]

Doctor Who – Smith and Jones (rant warning) [Jun. 30th, 2007|09:04 pm]
Stephan

Well from what I’ve seen so far I like Martha Jones. I think she’ll make a fine travelling companion to the Doctor, and I hope she doesn’t decide to quit early. I was disappointed when Mickey Smith stopped travelling in the TARDIS after only two episodes. One foreseeable problem with Martha is that she might stand out from the common people when they travel back into historic Britain.

As for the actual episode, they took 40 minutes to complete a story I can sum up two sentences. Rhinoceros shaped alien rent-a-cops teleport a hospital from the Earth to neutral territory on the moon in order to locate a shape-changing blood-drinking criminal alien. Believing the Doctor to be human, the criminal absorbs his blood, thereby failing to scan as human and is executed. Human casualties 2, alien casualties 3.

The episode disappointed me early on because at sight of the rhinoceros faces I hoped that the Kraals from "The Android Invasion" had returned. (just the lament of a fan from the classic era of the Doctor Who series). I’m not sure it was necessary for the troopers to bear similarity to an Earth animal, but I guess the personality of normal rhinos made it easy to identify with the disposition of the troopers.

What I found entirely unnecessary was the alien blood-drinker using a straw. As far as I’m concerned, sick humour like that has no place in Doctor Who, nor does the Doctor passionately performing a "genetic transfer."

In the closing scene I thought it very cute the way the Doctor referred to the gravitic anomaliser ("Horns of the Nimon") and the helmic regulator ("The Ark in Space"). It’s only a pity the scriptwriters can’t play on this devotion to continuity with a little more enthusiasm than mere quips.

linkReply

Comments:
[User Picture]From: dhlawrence
2007-06-30 04:00 pm (UTC)
I heard that they were going to be the Kraals, but that the staff changed their minds for some reason. More than one person was up in arms over that.

Yes, she does happen to stand out in historical times, as you'll soon see.

I thought that the straw was too much of a cheap laugh, but I did like the black marker used by the non-Kraals. I thought that was very Douglas Adams-ish.
(Reply) (Thread)
[User Picture]From: thefoxaroo
2007-07-01 03:26 am (UTC)
With that black marker imprinting I'm surprised that everyone in the hospital (including the fugitive) wasn't hunting around for marker pens. :roll:
(Reply) (Parent) (Thread)